This Is Probably The Wrong Situation To Cite China’s One-Child Policy

Malaysia MH370 Datuk Seri Mohamed Nazri Abdul Aziz

China’s one-child policy, enacted in 1979, has undoubtedly changed Chinese society. Whether for better — curbing population growth in a country with dire resource limitations — or for worse — creating a generation of “Little Emperors” who are doted on by two generations of extended family — remains a debate that may never been settled. Of course, there are places where this debate can both be stimulating and appropriate. In the context of missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 is not one of those places.

Here’s Malaysia Tourism and Culture Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Nazri Abdul Aziz, as quoted in Malaysia’s The Star:

“We have to understand that China has (had) a one-child policy for more than 30 years and for the families of passengers on the flight, they are worried and angered over the loss of their descendants,” he said when winding up the debate for his ministry on the motion of thanks for the royal address in the Dewan Negara, Monday.

…“The Chinese believe that for the final rites, the body must be touched. If not the body, at least they should know where the aircraft crashed.

“As both of these requirements are unfulfilled, they cannot conduct the final rites and in their frustration, they direct their anger at Malaysia.”

Is the implication that a child would be less valuable if a family had more than one, and the families of those Chinese victims would therefore be less angry at Malaysia?

Even if this was true, why say it out loud? As far as political parrying goes — deflecting blame, in this case — this is as clumsy as it comes. Are his listeners supposed to have an a-ha moment because Chinese anger has been put into context? Is his amateur psychoanalysis, paired with a rudimentary understanding of Chinese custom (the body must be touched), supposed to help victims overcome their grief? And what about the juxtaposition of tragic personal loss with the most controversial government policy of the last half-century? Where’s the consonance?

Seven and a half weeks after the disappearance of MH370, we still have no idea where it is. The victims are gone. Does more need to be said?

MH370: One-child policy, burial rites among factors for Chinese nationals’ outburst, says Nazri (The Star)

    2 Responses to “This Is Probably The Wrong Situation To Cite China’s One-Child Policy”

    1. Jahar

      I don’t think it implies that another child would be less valuable, just that having only one makes him more valuable. I don’t exactly agree with that, but lots of my students do.

    2. wai

      If you do not love all of your family members equally, that is your problem and not others.

      The despair and grief are the same if anyone in the family dead without valid reason.

      This ministry has a problem in valuing life, which makes him doesn’t qualify to own one, perhaps.


    Leave a Reply

    • (will not be published)

    XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    + 8 = seventeen