Save the lecture about historical context. We’re talking about rocks. Uninhabited rocks. If indeed there’s black gold inside the set of rocks known as the Diaoyu Islands, governments should mine ‘em together and split the profit, as was proposed once upon a time ago. But nooo, that would be too elementary a solution. We have to act like children, because we are, in the grand scheme of things. Children whose children behave like — shock! — children, flipping over police cars and boycotting products.
You reap what you sow. The government here — and, in the interest of fairness, the right wing of the Japanese government, which incited the latest round of street protest in China by sending 150 lawmakers etc. toward Diaoyu/Senkaku, then watching 10 activists land on them — has sowed nationalism, and reaps this shit:
The Chinese state news media portrayed the demonstrations as fairly small, each involving fewer than 200 people, and not extending to inland provinces. But photographs posted on Sina Weibo, the country’s most widely used microblogging service, suggested that the crowds had been far larger. In one photo said to be from the southwestern city of Chengdu, deep in China’s interior, the number of protesters appeared to be in the thousands.
“Defend the Diaoyu Islands to the death,” one banner said. Another said, “Even if China is covered with graves, we must kill all Japanese.”
The excellent South Sea Conversations adds about the dangers of nationalism:
The ICG’s Stephanie Kleine-Ahlbrandt recently commented that the leaders of China and Japan have little “political capital” to spend on defying “nationalist or populist sentiment”. In this excellent interview, SKA identifies nationalist sentiment as a constraint on governments’ ability to compromise or back down during a dispute. There are counter-examples, such as Noda’s governament’s speedy release of the recent protagonists, where Chinese and Japanese leaders have appeared to defy pressure to be uncooperative and confrontation. But the two countries’ recent record suggest this has beendifficult in the past.
Public opinion offers an explanation for what learned observers consider to be China’s counterproductively hardline stance in the previous Diaoyu confrontation in September 2010 (itself a response to Japan’s abnormally trenchant action in detaining an infringing Chinese fishing boat captain for several weeks rather than releasing him swiftly, as they did yesterday). The ill-will on the part of both publics may have had a lot to do with the non-implementation of a deal negotiated back in 2008 for cooperative development of some of the oil and gas deposits in the area.
Nationalist activists on both sides are true believers in their cause, so even where their actions may be deliberately incited and/or tacitly sanctioned by their governments, they nonetheless impact the dispute by necessitating responses from the other side. Once the Qifeng-2 escaped the clutches of the Hong Kong authorities and got beyond PRC territorial waters, for example, Beijing had little or no control over whether the passengers of the Qifeng-2 would actually manage to set foot on the island last Wednesday.
The “true believers” are manageable when they’re slinging virtual rocks on the Internet, but once cars get overturned — police cars – then shit has gotten real. Look:
So, good luck, governments. Keep on fiddling with the people’s emotions and watch as your self-interests are cut from under your feet. Yay nationalistic fervor and all that garbage. Mobs are always great until they stop listening — the biggest fools are those who believe they ever listened in the first place.
“Even if China is covered with graves, we must kill all Japanese.”
Yeah, like that worked out so well the last time China tried.
No country that has anything truly to be proud of continuously proclaims their humiliation and focuses foreign policy of a long past war. Chinese people’s continual eruption of issues involving Japan isn’t so much a side effect of nationalism, but that of a cowardly and backward people who lack any degree of self confidence. If we could compare the average Chinaren’s psychological makeup to that of the Columbine Shooters, I’m sure they’d be indiscernible one from the other. In the end China will get what it deserves. “Little” Japan and “Little” Britain put put the bloated China behemoth in its place before and someday they or another “little” country will do it again.
I totally agree with you! Well said.
Urgh… yeah, I’m sure your bigotry and hard-on for imperialism make you an infinitely better human being than the car-overturners.
Hardly bigotry, there will always be many that will turn on their countrymen for personal gain. See as all those funds are sucked out of China and into gated Chinese compounds in Canada etc.
Looks like they really went amok in Shenzhen… Well I for one would like to see more wanton (wonton?) destruction of vehicles paid for by those protesting! Destroy Wujing, PLA and Gong An vehicles to the death!!!
Wonder what column this fits in for auto insurance purposes?
“Hello, yes my car was attacked and overturned by a angry mob in Shenzhen…. Yes, it was a Japanese car but I don’t see what tha… Excuse me I don’t think I’m a running-dog… No, I don’t think I was asking for it…”
I would be pretty pissed if I went shopping and came back to discover my car was trashed. I bet half these people were hired by BYD/Geely.
The thing that annoys me is that the Chinese media is ALL OVER THIS because it’s a protest against EVIL IMPERIALIST JAPAN and we need to try and understand that FEELINGS ARE RUNNING HIGH over the Senkaku dispute.
But, when Wukan was surrounded by a thousand police officers trying to starve out the villagers… Hot DAMN, everything is SO HARMONIOUS!
Indeed, rocks in their heads…or should that be islands? (Sorry, someone had to make that terrible pun!)
Also apologies for the typos. High time i got the wordpress app.