To No One’s Surprise, Gu Kailai Given Suspended Death Sentence

In the most non-suspenseful verdict ever, a court in Hefei, Anhui province (read: the Party) has officially sentenced Gu Kailai to “death with a two-year reprieve” for murdering Neil Heywood, as expected. What this means is that Gu will not be put to death, assuming she doesn’t commit another crime in the next two years. And then it’s off to a plush retirement home — sorry, prison – and no one will remember any of this.

With all due respect to Heywood’s family and associates, if you’re related to a high-level Chinese official here and want to kill someone, make sure the would-be victim is insignificant, has few connections with other Chinese bosses, and, oh yeah, it helps if you have friends within the CCP. Gu Kailai obviously does. She’ll be just fine — though we hear cancer is less forgiving than the Party.


“We respect the court’s decision,” said He Zhengsheng, a lawyer for the Heywood family. He and another witness to the hearing – which was barred to all but a few journalists from official Chinese media – revealed the verdict to throngs of reporters waiting outside the court in eastern Hefei city.

They both also said Zhang Xiaojun, an aide to the Bo household, was sentenced to nine years in prison for acting as an accomplice to the poisoning of Heywood.

As for what this means for Bo Xilai, that is the real mystery. Will he face criminal charges? Could he possibly? We’re about to find out whether he has stronger friends or enemies. Stay tuned.

UPDATE, 12:04 pm: Here’s Donald C. Clarke again with an explanation for why Gu could serve as few as 15 years:

Under Art. 78 of the Criminal Law and a 2011 Supreme People’s Court directive, those sentenced to life imprisonment or a term of years (including as a result of a commuted death sentence) may have their sentences reduced for good behavior (that’s my own term; Chinese law speaks of showing repentance or establishing merit) during their imprisonment. And various forms of good behavior are listed, including (in the 2011 SPC directive) paying compensation. Presumably that will not be a problem for Gu.

But there are limits: Art. 78 of the Criminal Law states that a death sentence commuted to life imprisonment may under no circumstances be reduced to less than 25 years of actual time served, and a death sentence commuted to 25 years’ imprisonment may under no circumstances be reduced to less than 20 years of actual time served, in each case counting from the date of the original commutation. And even less is possible: in its 2011 directive, the Supreme People’s Court simply overrode the Criminal Law and stated that a commuted sentence could ultimately be reduced to as little as 15 years of actual time served. [ADDITION: A colleague also points out the intriguing possibilities of medical parole even earlier.]

    8 Responses to “To No One’s Surprise, Gu Kailai Given Suspended Death Sentence”

    1. narsfweasels

      Sickening, really. That mentally ill guy from the UK who was tricked into carrying drugs got death, and someone who actually PLANS a murder gets off without so much as a slap on the wrist.

    2. Chinese Netizen

      Would be sweet if she had to serve out her sentence in the same room Neil was executed in at that resort in CQ.

    3. King Tubby

      What, room 1065 in the Lucky Holiday Hotel.

      Anticipating this rotten result, I cancelled my sports book and lost a lucrative new revenue stream.

      Originally went for two in the brain pan and a soft landing in some shallow landfill on the outskirts of Chongqing.

      Just terrible.

      China just doesn’t play fair.

    4. Harold Titsonbely

      Salutations,what drives the Chinese people’s response to corruption?I hope that justice is upheld,as an example to all classes.We in America have narcissium to confront,the idea that one is special,thus rules dont apply.The demonstrators may benifit by focusing on holding everybody to account for actions that harm the majority.Being humble is what is needed,worldwide.


    Leave a Reply

    • (will not be published)

    XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    − 6 = three