Mark Kitto, Back To China Dreaming

The author, trying to look academic

The author, trying to look academic

A year after leaving China and five years after publishing his first book (China Cuckoo: How I Lost a Fortune and Found a Life in China), Mark Kitto has a follow-up, That’s China, technically a prequel that traces the beginning of his That’s magazine franchise and looks underneath the fingernail of Chinese publishing. Kitto wrote the following column for Prospect, republished here with the author’s permission — with a freshly appended postscript.

From 2008 to 2012, I wrote a column for Prospect called China Café about life on a Chinese mountain, Moganshan, near Shanghai. In 2013 I left China, having written a final sign-off article, You’ll Never be Chinese. My basic argument was: “The Communist Party has destroyed civil society, the education system sucks, and there will be a major upheaval, economic and social, very soon, so I’m off.” Once it was published, I found somewhere more congenial to live, the coast of North Norfolk, which has been my UK base for most of my life.

I’ve been home now for 18 months, one month for every year I lived in China, and I am beginning to understand China again in a way I had forgotten. I have returned to the China Dream. It’s all around me, even in Norfolk. Young people tell me with breathless excitement how they are studying Mandarin at school or have a trip to China planned for their gap year. Can I help with language practice, travel advice, an introduction to an internship, a job in the mountain-top coffee shop which my Chinese wife Joanna still runs from Norfolk?

Then there are the adult dreamers. The parents pushing the children at me, the local businesses wanting to “break into the China market,” the businesses being courted by Chinese investors, the Norfolk attractions wanting to pull in Chinese tourists.

Most awkward are the conversations with the people in charge of the attractions. They’ve read about tourist boom from China and want a share of it, but Norfolk has no duty-free shopping village, no iconic British landmark and when the royal family are here, they hide. I don’t think there will be a flood of Chinese tourists coming this way any time soon.

The business people are more realistic. I’ve met several who’ve had their fingers burnt in China. They enjoy hearing how I had mine chopped off and stir-fried. It makes them feel better. Those still engaged or committed to China are more taciturn. They fall into a strange silence when I ask them how they are getting on.

The worst dreamer — the dream-makers — are the mainstream news media and the government. Soon after I returned home in 2013, the Education Minister Elizabeth Truss visited China and raved about the superiority of the Chinese education system—the same oppressive, creativity-stifling system that drove my family back to the UK. Thanks to her being a local Norfolk MP, and local schools reportedly in a dire state, the coverage was extensive. Yet my children have been transformed since they left the Chinese system and entered the British/Norfolk one.

In China they spent the entire 12-hour school day at their desks, ate their meals at them, and took tests, and mock tests, and revised for tests. It was not an education. They were learning how to pass exams. They suffered mentally and physically. My son’s mild learning “problem” went undiscovered.

Here in Norfolk they have blossomed. They enjoy school. My son’s problem has been identified and dealt with. Where he used to hate reading, he now wants to show off his skill. The pair of them have discovered team sports, and love them. (The Communist Party of China does not like teams, other than their own.)

While sections of the UK media are at last beginning to ponder the potential downturn in the Chinese economy — the repercussions of which no-one dares quantify with any accuracy, if that were possible — still the government and most of the media talk up the “China Dream,” a phrase coined by President Xi Jinping. According to one report, British investment in China is due to quadruple. China invests more in the UK than any other EU country, according to the government. The British establishment think we are marching with Mao’s legacy towards some sort of economic Shangri-La.

Combining education, investment, and the dream — the word was in the title of the piece — all in one, I read with horror a recent article in The Telegraph by Anthony Seldon, the Master of Wellington College, describing what “fun” it was to open British branded schools in China, how America was on the way down, China up, and we should all, like him, be learning Mandarin.

Now I understand why I used to meet so many outsiders trying to get into China, as I had once done myself — a very different China, before the modern Party ruined its chances, 30 years ago. They all believe in the dream. And having spent so long there myself, working with one of the most efficient propaganda — dream-peddling — machines in the world, I have been reminded that telling people what to think is not a political practice exclusive to totalitarian states. Democratic ones do it well too, perhaps even better.

When one of the most respected educators in the country admits to being a window-staring daydreamer perhaps I should think twice about bringing my children home for school after all. At least back in China there was no point staring out of the window. The air was so polluted you couldn’t see anything.

I’m due to give a lecture on “Doing business in China” at the end of this month. I joke it will be one word long: “Don’t.” Of course it won’t be. The students have been given my book to read so I hope they’ll have some questions. But it will be tempting to round up five minutes early and tell them: “My final word on doing business in China: turn to that window, look outside, and start dreaming.”

~

POSTSCRIPT for BJC:

Not that I wasn’t hoping it would be, but the feedback to the lecture, duly delivered to eight (mostly interested) undergrads on a business course BA, was along the lines of: “Well that was different.”

Transpires that the previous nine lectures (I was given the prime slot of the tenth and final one, quite by chance) were the more usual and upbeat “we must all engage with China and this is how and it’ll be a challenge but don’t worry I’m going to tell you how to avoid all the bad stuff and the best way to do that is ignore it and get on with giving you the China Dream because that’s what you’re here for…”

As ever, and as I wrote in the article above, the British media were a handy teaching aid. A couple of days before the lecture the Telegraph ran a story titled, “It’s time for the world to adjust to China’s global ambition,” whose main peg was the “longest bridge in the world… across the Yangtze Delta.” Apparently the Yangtze Delta is 102 miles wide. It wasn’t when I drove over it in 2013 on my way home to the UK. A modicum of research reveals the “bridge” is in fact a particular stretch of the elevated viaduct above the rice paddy on the Beijing to Shanghai gaotie. And we all know why the gaotie is elevated. It’s because the government is terrified of the peasants whose land it would have to otherwise requisition and all the social instability that might follow. Hence the vast additional expense of sticking the entire Chinese rail network on top of concrete pillars.

(Next up in the ever-reliable Telegraph: On 13 April a hilarious piece of puffery about the Shanghai stock exchange ending with the words: “As they say in China, it will make for interesting times.” They don’t say that in China. The author is misquoting, as do countless other Western journalists: “May you live in uninteresting times.” Uninteresting is safe. Idiots.)

I could write a regular column about the latest tripe to be spouted by the British media about China. It’s regular and relentless, yet would soon become uninteresting.

Back to my students. They wrote nice thank-you emails. They still want to do business in China, but they say they will be more cautious, and better prepared. They will even recommend that I come and talk to the next year’s course. I appreciate that.

Seems like there is a market for China Reality, despite the efforts of the British establishment.

Mark Kitto’s newest book is That’s China, available on Amazon and select bookstores in Beijing and Shanghai (including The Bookworm and Garden Books).

38 Responses to “Mark Kitto, Back To China Dreaming”

  1. jixiang

    I clicked on the link to the article by Britain’s education minister.

    It ends like this: “As for Shanghai, its dazzling new infrastructure might be its public face – and first-time visitors like me will be awed by its incredible architecture. But its skyscrapers, and its ambitions, are all built on maths. That respect for the subject, matched with that belief in every single child, is what should really inspire us.”

    A belief in every single child? In China? It’s amazing how easily casual visitors to China are hoodwinked.

    Reply
  2. Pete

    And he should keep a close eye on his son too since he’s got a Chinese mother who hates her own country/culture and a white father who makes a living out of bashing China. Sounds like the perfect recipe for the next Elliot Rodger.

    Reply
      • Pete

        I didn’t say that. Read his “You’ll Never Be Chinese” article. His wife supposedly hates China almost as much as him.

        Reply
      • Pete

        I didn’t say that. Read up on his earlier piece “You’ll Never Be Chinese”. His wife comes off as a typical flighty Chinese woman who can’t wait to leave China for good. Their kids will be raised in a household where part of their heritage becomes a constant source of scorn.

        Reply
        • jixiang

          All it says in the essay is that his wife lost her reservations about leaving China the day that she started using Weibo.

          So she had reservations. It hardly sounds like she “couldn’t wait to leave China”. And even if she did, that doesn’t necessarily mean she hates her heritage. I know a lot of Chinese who want to leave China because of the undeniable problems of the place, and they still don’t “hate their culture”.

          Reply
          • RhZ

            They left China. That means they must hate their culture, according to Pete the genius.

            They don’t live under the yoke of the party like Pete does. That makes Pete mad. Why should he suffer while they do not?

  3. Tristram Eve

    If I recall correctiy, there were two”Why I’m Leaving China” pieces at that time. One by Kitto, in which he lambasted China because he played and lost, and another one by Chris Devonshire-Ellis, in which he stated how he’d won. Kitto got a lot of blog coverage because he failed, Devonshire lambasted and mocked because he was successful. I dug out the latters original article, it’s still online here: http://www.china-briefing.com/news/2012/08/14/im-leaving-china.html
    If you read that it makes you see Kitto as a wringing loser. I’m still at a loss as to why we slag off those who obviously enjoyed China and did well. If you want a role model for China the choice seems fairly clear. Maybe it’s time to reappraise our most hated expat CDE. I know whose tips I’d rather follow and who I’d rather have a China beer with and it ain’t the Norfolk boy.

    Reply
    • Chinese Netizen

      CDE left because he was forced to. He still glorifies China because he needs to. For his businesses continued existence.
      That’s about it.

      Reply
      • Ed Balls *

        I don’t think anyone “forced” CDE to leave. And anyway I saw him in Shanghai last December having a good time. Legend mate and a successful one.

        Reply
        • Chinese Netizen

          He was very much compelled to leave at the time. Nice to know he’s back to his old ways. Wonder if he’s done the Shekou circuit yet…

          Reply
  4. The All Seeing Eye *

    A great article on why he left China. Devonshire’s that is, not Kitto’s.
    And Devonshire is even funny in hindsight he takes the piss out of hisself. Kitto is too up his arse about the Chinese ripping him off. I guess we missed that at the time.

    Damn I might even have to take back all the nasty stuff I said about CDE now. Fuck.
    “Devonshire-Ellis probably alright China geezer after all shocker” LOL

    Reply
    • RhZ

      So, based on nothing new at all, you find yourself compelled to re-evaluate your opinion of CDE? Yeah, right.

      Reply
  5. Capita Nervorsa *

    Mark Kitto doesn’t look academic. He looks like a fucking allotment gardener. And highly defensive with his arms crossed like that. What a twat!

    Reply
  6. Firewall *

    Beijing Creams commentary at the time. It was all about Devonshire-Ellis and not about Kitto. “So long and thanks for all the bullshit” http://beijingcream.com/2012/08/so-long-and-thanks-for-all-the-bullshit-baron-christopher-devonshire-ellis-exits-china/ 171 comments.
    One wonders about the likes of RFH (aka Robert Foyle Hunwick) and their incentive to do that.
    I think we should be told: Who the fuck is Mark Kitto? And more importantly, who the fuck is Robert Foyle Hunwick to pass judgement on expats in China?
    Does anyone know who RFH is? Because he talks a lot on Beijing Cream about all kinds of shite. So if you’re calling people out include your own. Devonshire may or not be a cunt. Kitto is a loser. But who the fuck are Anthony Tao & Robert Foyle Hunwick? I think we should be told, and if not here then maybe on other blogs. I find it weird that your cool guys are losers. And your wankers are those who did good. Like…huh?

    Reply
  7. China Jimbo *

    RFH is a stink tramp charity shop FOARP and like a lot of these fakes tried to get attention by slating well known expats. It didn’t do FOARP any good (last seen slumming it in Poland, and considered China-unemployable) and RFH isn’t exactly setting the journo world alight either, even with his “Foyle Hunwick” alter ego. He got dumped by the Atlantic after all. As for Kitto, he’s a spolit army brat and ran away when it got tough. Dodgy media licensing, he knew the risk and didn’t man up. If you’d been here long enough you’d know that. Hey Mark! Turn yer collar up! Or is your wife busy fucking Devonshit for his money and your house rent and kids education? Fuck off Norfolk Boy. You’re not in Shanghai anymore.

    Reply
  8. Jessica Wong *

    Ahem. Mark Kitto didn’t start “That’s” like he claims. Kathleen Lao a Canadian-Chinese girl did. Kitto worked for her as a contributor until she left to go to Vancouver. She licensed the titles too him and he fucked it up. The same Kathleen as in “Kathleen’s” on Mintian Guangshan People Park the old racecourse in Shanghai. She’s still there now back from Canada go ask her about Kitto. You’ll get a different story about his being a stupid wanker who fucked up her publishing business. Most Chinese girls in Shanghai who know him remember his wandering hands and drunken approaches and feel very sorry for Joanna.

    Reply
    • Apples & Pears *

      I don’t think you’d get Chris on here to be honest. It’s not shall we say his “cup of tea”.
      But the contrast between him and Kitto is interesting. One whinges, the other doesn’t. It’s obvious who is preferable company. Who wants to spend an evening with a whiny middle aged scarecrow with a chip on his shoulder?

      Reply
      • Chinese Netizen

        Or a pompous douchebag who can’t stop spouting off how amazing he is, how many CCP officials he’s gone spa hopping with and then becoming not-too-comfortably combative and generally annoying (CDE). Not exactly preferable company.
        First hand experience.

        Reply
  9. Anthony Tao

    Hi everyone, I’ve used an asterisk to indicate which comments on this thread come from the same IP address. As in: all asterisked comments share the same IP, every non-asterisked comment originates from a unique IP.

    Carry on.

    Reply
    • Chinese Netizen

      Fucking HILARIOUS…someone is up burning the midnight oil, nursing a bottle of cheap Filipino rum and praising hisself?

      Reply
    • Bruce

      Excellent work, Anthony! I appreciate the insight your asterisks bring.

      I’m not pro- or anti-Kitto. As someone who has worked and lived in China for almost three decades, it’s evident that each of us has his or her own unique experience.

      It would be nice to read intelligent comments about Kitto’s views. It’s a pity when the commentary becomes so petty, if not just downright nasty.

      Reply
  10. Sergei

    Where is this IP address? Maybe if you give it other blogs can be seeing if this CDE spammer is also making this nasty mess on their blog too. You do us all a favor we out him from all his pathetic postings about himself.

    Reply
  11. Paulus Ljunberg

    I’m always suspicious about these things here.
    1) this only seems to happen on Beijing Cream
    2) it seems regular every few months
    3) I read other China blogs it not is happening there
    4) I read the China Briefing I think Chris too busy doing other things bother about this crap.
    5) so there is the potential some naughty people or even you (there is obvious grudge against him) do this for your own motivation, spite or maybe generate controversy and more hits.
    Just my opinion but this whole thing on Beijing Cream about Devonshire-Ellis is just very strange and repetitive and doesn’t feel right or true. I personally think someone or you does this for your own “fun”.

    Reply
    • Anthony Tao

      >> “this whole thing on Beijing Cream about Devonshire-Ellis is just very strange”

      You used the name, not I.

      Reply
  12. Eric the Half a Bee

    On Facebook he’s in Malta so you can check the IP. I think this is another wind up though by BC or one of its wind up merchant readers I don’t think even Chris would be this much of an twat. Love or loathe the man he did make a success in China. Not everyone inc. fellow Brits like Kitto appreciates that. So CDE as (successful) wanker comes across on the blogs I think fueled mainly by jealousy and it’s become a fashionable thing to do.

    Reply
  13. David

    He does sound like a sore loser with a huge chip on his shoulder, and try to discourage anyone which is not thinking like him to avoid doing business in China.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


9 − = three